Home
entries friends calendar user info BrandonSanderson.com Previous Previous Next Next

Advertisement

Mistborn - Reader Mail
Weblog for Writer Brandon Sanderson
mistborn
[info]mistborn
Add to Memories
Tell a Friend
Reader Mail

I got an interesting email the other day.  I'm not sure what to make of it.  Perhaps you all can interpret for me:

I am furious at my new found understanding that there will be no further installment of Elantris. I was under the impression that Mistborn was the second installment of the series, but no, it a entirely different book altogether. I don't understand why your not making another book to at least finish the story that you produced through Elantris. The book is UNFINISHED. There is no ending. What happens to Roaden and the other elantrians? What happens to the war between the Elantrians and the Wyrm? You didn't explain one-fourth of the **** you wrote in that book, and I was expecting an explanation in the second and possibly third installment. You screwed me. I have these unanswered questions that will never be answered because you have forgotten a crucial rule to being a writer. You never leave a story UNFINISHED. I have to say that after realizing that you would actually do something as horrible as publish an unfinished piece of literature and then claim to not finish it, without a doubt makes you the worst author... no... you don't deserve to be called an author. An author wouldn't do this to his reader, his fan, his own **** creation. I do not regret to inform you that i will not be reading anymore of your trash in the fear that the book/garbage will not be completed due to you lack of professionalism. You don't deserve your hands, eyes and mind for this sin against literature. I know you won't care about what i write. You'll probably delete this and mistake it for a piece of hate mail. No, Brandon Sanderson this is not some trash talker trying to make you feel bad in hopes of making you feel like **** for what you have done, even-though that would be nice. No, this was a fan who you disappointed and caused that fan to lose faith in you, your writing, and your characters who's actions and morals were just lies that you couldn't give a **** for.  I hope you lose your ability to write so that you can fully understand and appreciate the joys that came with that of a completed accomplishment for you would! never know that feeling of joy again.

Sincerely, with all the malice and frustration i can muster without physically assaulting you,

[Name Removed by Brandon.  Also, some edits were made by Brandon to remove curse words.  Otherwise, that's exactly how I got it.]

So, what do you think?  I'm honestly not sure I even want to reply to that.  If I were to, I don't know even how to approach it.  I could:

1)  Explain that NO story is ever finished.  Is LoTR done just because Frodo is gone?  Do any stories ever end as long as there are people alive?  We have to choose, as authors, to end somewhere.  With Elantris, this is the ending I chose.

2)  Explain that in my opinion, the ending to ELANTRIS is very complete.  No, you don't know everything about the future of the characters, but the major conflicts introduced in the opening chapters are resolved by the end of the book.  Sure, there are hints that there is more, but I often do that at the end of stories so that the reader can continue to imagine where the characters go and what happens in the world.  I want my stories to continue to live after I finish them, even if I never return to that setting. 

3)  I've never been sure that I won't do an ELANTRIS sequel.  Just because I often say I have no concrete plans as to when I'll get back to the world doesn't mean I won't some day.  How long did it take Stephen King to get back to Dark Tower?  What about Orson Scott Card and his Alvin Maker series?  Chances are good that there will someday be an ELANTRIS sequel.  It's just not on the list of things I'm actively writing right now.

4)  Calm down!  I'm glad my story had such a powerful effect on you, but it's not worth this level of emotion. 

5)  Mistborn, by the way, DOES continue on and has some really nifty resolution in Book Three.  But...er...it's not out yet, so I can't prove that to you.

6) If you want to be more close to the ELANTRIS world, you could always buy a nice Aon pendant.  (Hint hint.)

Any other responses you folks can think up?  I doubt I'll actually respond to this; it's pretty negative.  But, then, those of you who know me understand that I'm something of a peacemaker at heart, and I like to try to smooth out negative emotions in people when I can. 

Either way, maybe the email there will be an interesting read for you, and give you a bit of a glimpse into what it's like to be a public figure, if only a minor one like myself.

Comments
Page 1 of 2
[1] [2]
mariness From: [info]mariness Date: April 18th, 2008 09:43 pm (UTC) (Link)
Ursula Le Guin said she wouldn't write any further Earthsea stories, and then did. (Some of which ended up not satisfying anybody, but that's a different story.) Arthur Conan Doyle killed off Holmes, and then brought him back. I could go on. But that's why I'm inclined towards 3 -- I see no reason to say that you'll never write about these characters again. And honestly it might be interesting to see what you think about those characters 10 or 15 years down the line.
amurderofcrows From: [info]amurderofcrows Date: April 18th, 2008 09:43 pm (UTC) (Link)
You ought to see the mail that RK Milholland gets for his webcomic Something Positive. It makes that look tame. You could be getting mail about your character's sex lives, after all.
silveraspen From: [info]silveraspen Date: April 18th, 2008 09:48 pm (UTC) (Link)
Oh dear. How incredibly unfair.

I don't think I'd respond to that, if I were you. Don't respond, don't engage, don't escalate the situation.

(Have you ever read security consultant Gavin de Becker's work? It's depressing and a shame that such things are even needed, but I always thought it had some very good advice.)
lucasarcher From: [info]lucasarcher Date: April 18th, 2008 09:50 pm (UTC) (Link)
I wouldn't even dignify that trash with a response. No matter what you say, this guy is obviously too emotional to really understand what goes into writing fiction, and the purpose of fiction in general (like oh my god, Hamlet was unfinished because we never find out if Fortinbras is able to rule Denmark well and we never really find out if Hamlet was crazy and if Horatio remained in Denmark to help Fortinbras out, Shakespeare was such a hack).
clytemnestra215 From: [info]clytemnestra215 Date: April 18th, 2008 10:06 pm (UTC) (Link)
Well...Shakespeare was a hack. He was just a very good one. << >>
(no subject) - [info]lucasarcher
(no subject) - [info]clytemnestra215
elle_cosette From: [info]elle_cosette Date: April 18th, 2008 10:01 pm (UTC) (Link)
Thanks for sharing that letter. Are you used to receiving negative mail yet? Now that you are becoming more and more well known, I suppose you will have to be. I'm trying to imagine it.

It's interesting to see the way each mind reacts to the same words, isn't it? I read the identical book this guy did, and yet the story ending felt satisfying to me. It's a good reminder for me as I write.

Margot
clytemnestra215 From: [info]clytemnestra215 Date: April 18th, 2008 10:02 pm (UTC) (Link)
The whole world is made of different people with different tastes and ideals and levels of quality. One might hazard a guess that this guy sees things a bit differently than you do!

Can't please everyone. I wouldn't bother replying if it were me. Some people just want to be upset, and no one can change their minds if they don't want to change them.
firesion From: [info]firesion Date: April 18th, 2008 10:03 pm (UTC) (Link)
That does not deserve a reply. If I was you I might if feeling generous write a sequel to Elantris as a writers practice activity. You know they type where they say tell a whole story in 3 words/sentences. Then send it to him. On the other hand people who send those types of e-mails would probably miss any meaning you sent and see it just as a reason to harass you.

I can say I did like Elantris and would love to see another novel in that series.
yedijoda From: [info]yedijoda Date: April 18th, 2008 10:30 pm (UTC) (Link)
He must have liked Elantris a whole heckuva lot to be willing to put all that effort into writing this email complaining that there isn't a sequel and complaining about needing more background and more information about the world and more story, and more, more, more . . .

Poor guy. Despite what he's written, I bet he'll read every single book you write. It's rather funny that this rant is the only way he could think of to make sure that you'd actually read and respond to his opinion. And it worked.

Congrats on the love hate mail. ^_^ If it were me, I'd respond in kind--ranting about how much I love hate fans like him who are so demanding. But that's just me.
cartazon From: [info]cartazon Date: April 18th, 2008 10:32 pm (UTC) (Link)
You should be flattered that your book made him care so much to write such an impassioned letter. At least, that's what I tell myself when I get mail like that for my work (not fiction, yet). A negative response is better than no response.
hopses From: [info]hopses Date: April 18th, 2008 10:32 pm (UTC) (Link)
Maybe send an "I'm sorry you feel that way. (Oh, well)." (You could also insert a "too bad" in the parentheses or a "pooh-pooh to you too."

I've got to admit that I can understand (to some extent—and that extent is not NEARLY the extent s/he feels) the writer's frustration. You're a great writer, and I've enjoyed what I've read a lot.

However, you do seem to have a habit of voicing a number of questions in the Epilogue. It's not such a big deal in Mistborn, because we know you're going back to it, but in Elantris it was a rather frustrating. (You can ask my husband—we read the last chapter and I was nodding "that's a nice ending," and then we read the epilogue and I think I shrieked, "WHAT? AND HE'S NOT WRITING A SEQUEL?!")

It's one thing to leave some questions unanswered, but it seems a feels like you're taunting the reader (read: me) by pointing out all these questions that you didn't answer. It's a kinda irritating.


pixelfish From: [info]pixelfish Date: April 18th, 2008 10:36 pm (UTC) (Link)
I'm just boggled that this person doesn't feel that Elantris is a full and complete story in its own right. (And even if it wasn't finished, how is that a sin against literature? Paging Messieurs Dickens, Marlowe, Tolkien and Twain.)

And how could he think Mistborn was a sequel? Reading the cover copy made that pretty clear to me that here was a brand new universe.

I wouldn't respond to it because how much effort do you want to go to appease somebody who just doesn't get it. Better to put the effort into writing for those who will enjoy it. :)

therinth From: [info]therinth Date: April 18th, 2008 10:44 pm (UTC) (Link)
Don't respond. He wants to engage with you, and responding will only encourage his entitled feelings -- perhaps not with you, but with other authors, or in other situations that he feels this way. It's not worth it to be the nice guy in this situation, when the other party is obviously crazy.

I fear writing the next Wheel of Time will only open you up to more of this sort of thing :/.
pixelfish From: [info]pixelfish Date: April 19th, 2008 04:33 pm (UTC) (Link)
Yeah, I'd forgotten about that. I've even said stuff about the Wheel of Time that comes off as entitled fangirlism. (Reading Brandon's posts has made me rethink the job of author from a new perspective. Also, I re-read the series based on Brandon's posts, and while I still find aspects of it problematical, I think by and large, I've regained the respect I had for Jordan when I first started reading the books. Making a story work is HARD.)
raisinfish From: [info]raisinfish Date: April 18th, 2008 10:56 pm (UTC) (Link)
Wow. Just wow. I thought the book was finished. *sticks tongue out at naysayer.*
ehadams From: [info]ehadams Date: April 18th, 2008 11:06 pm (UTC) (Link)
He sounds like someone who wants his hand held when reading a book. Not everything can or will be explained in good novels. That leaves you some mystery, something to think about, and something to possibly build on later. I thought Elantris ended perfectly. I hope for a sequel of course, but I don't feel like the story is incomplete without one either.
From: [info]318_ross_5 Date: April 18th, 2008 11:28 pm (UTC) (Link)
So... what was that whole thing about the Wyrm? I thought that was from Werewolf in the World of Darkness. Maybe I should read Elantris again, but I don't remember anything about the Wyrm in the book.
mistborn From: [info]mistborn Date: April 18th, 2008 11:34 pm (UTC) (Link)
I think he means Wyrn, the emperor of Fjorden. Hrathen's ultimate boss, Regent of all Creation, yada yada.
(no subject) - [info]318_ross_5
firebyrd From: [info]firebyrd Date: April 18th, 2008 11:35 pm (UTC) (Link)
I agree that you shouldn't respond. The writer of this letter is, unfortunately, a bit of a nut, someone who has become so emotionally connected to your world that s/he is lashing out. The fact that you've managed to evoke such an emotional response actually speaks quite well of your writing.
agilebrit From: [info]agilebrit Date: April 18th, 2008 11:45 pm (UTC) (Link)
*blinks* The sense of entitlement is strong with this one.

You know, I'm the Queen of Open-Ended Endings. At least half the fanfiction I wrote back in the day could have used a sequel or six, and I constantly had people asking me for more. In fact, at the end of the story I consider my crowning achievement in fanfic, I specifically said in an author's note that there would be no sequel--mainly because the story squicked the snot out of me and I didn't want to visit that scenario again--precisely so I wouldn't have people saying "But you can't just leave it there!" I can and I did. Get over it. (Yes, I wrote a story that I squicked myself with. Shut up. I hate my brain sometimes.)

But never did I have anyone ask for a sequel in such a rude manner as your letter writer. Apparently TV fandom doesn't have a monopoly on bratty behavior. I'm frankly gobsmacked.
elvenpath From: [info]elvenpath Date: April 18th, 2008 11:53 pm (UTC) (Link)
LOL

No, I'm seriously. Wow. That made my night.

Okay, but on a more serious note.

I think you should just send back what you wrote here, maybe with a bit more detail. This person doesn't seem like they're incapable of understanding rational thought, like so many people here seem to believe. Give em a chance, and on your second email from them you'll be able to figure out if they're just a silly troll or not.

But if they are a silly troll, they definitely get 10/10 from me. A+ work.
insane_fae From: [info]insane_fae Date: April 19th, 2008 12:00 am (UTC) (Link)
Trust me that is one "fan" that i'm not sure you want. You have never eluded to s sequel to that series thus he should have never expected one. Now i know an author (love her books) who has eluded to a 3 installment in her Exiles series and i know of many people who have been waiting years for her book. Actually none of even know if she's still alive, so no don't respond to him, he didn't have the right to do this to you. He'll settle down in time and hopefully he'll grow up and realize that just because you don't make a sequel right away or at all that does not mean that your not an author. Sorry for such a long response.
superwench83 From: [info]superwench83 Date: April 19th, 2008 12:56 am (UTC) (Link)
Wow. The only conclusion I can draw from this is that this person is clearly unbalanced. To attack you as a person simply because he hated the end of the book? Me, I would just write back with something simple like, "I'm sorry you feel this way," or whatever. Someone who's this... well, insane, I don't think will understand any rational explanation you could give. It seems to me that this reader's mind is already made up, and nothing anyone can say could change it.
From: (Anonymous) Date: April 19th, 2008 02:14 am (UTC) (Link)

Literature Rage

Posted this over in facebook as well but wasn't sure if you check that - Fiona

I'd go with the “not responding to him directly” choice. In general, engaging with irrational individuals is never a great idea - it always just seems to degenerate further as they attempt to justify the righteousness of their rage.

I suppose you could respond to the issue more broadly if you wanted in terms of a section on the website or a Q&A on how a writer determines which plot lines are wrapped up and how much ambiguity can remain at the end of a novel and still have the overall story arc be complete.

I don’t actually think that an author OWES a reader anything other than a well written story. An author doesn’t owe a reader prequels or sequels so long as the story arc in the novel is complete. So I admit, that selfishly, when Robert Jordan died and before I found out you were penning the last novel, that I had a minor moment of panic when I thought - oh no what will happen to Perrin and Faile. But if in the end, Jordan’s estate had not been able to find anyone to complete the WOT, I don’t think I would have flown into a case of Literature Rage.

I've never actually been privy to an act of Literature Rage before. Perhaps the writer of the note suffers from some deep-seated abandonment issues that trigger an intense emotional reaction echoing with former abandonment situations.

Final Thought:

In a weird way, this is the flip of readers who abandon authors because the series is taking too long to resolve the story arcs and then those readers get their knickers in a knot because they think that the author is milking the series and abusing the fans commitment to the characters world for filthy lucre :)

I guess that means you can't win and you'll just have to be true to your own vision (I partly jest) about when a story arc is resolved.
rhylinn From: [info]rhylinn Date: April 19th, 2008 02:19 am (UTC) (Link)
All I have to say is that what fun is it if you know every detail of a story? Nothing is left to the imagination, so there's almost no point in re-reading something like that. In my opinion, that would read much like a textbook. Oh, and some people are just so immature. -.-'
speakerwiggin From: [info]speakerwiggin Date: April 19th, 2008 02:49 am (UTC) (Link)
Wow. This person needs to look up "entitled" in the dictionary and then sit in the corner and think about what he or she has done.

I fear the ending to Angel and or the Sopranos would send this person over the edge.

Er, further over it.
42ndblog From: [info]42ndblog Date: April 19th, 2008 03:17 am (UTC) (Link)
My suggestion:

Dear Mr./Ms. Irate Fan,

If you feel there is no ending, go ahead and write your own ending if it makes you feel better. Just please don't infringe on my copyright.


Seriously, it's okay Brandon. People get made, some people more than others. A thousand people could be in a room when the lights go off and at least a hundred people would say the lights are still on.

Sorry you have to deal with such rudeness.
qirien From: [info]qirien Date: April 19th, 2008 03:35 am (UTC) (Link)
Just send him a link to this blog post. That way you can say all these things without wasting more time on it. :-)

The Elantris pendants look AWESOME, BTW.
62 comments or Leave a comment
Page 1 of 2
[1] [2]
profile
mistborn
User: [info]mistborn
Name: mistborn
calendar
Back July 2009
1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031
about this journal
Brandon Sanderson writes epic fantasy novels for Tor Books. Find his novels, MISTBORN and ELANTRIS in any fine bookstore. More information on his website.
page summary
tags