Home
entries friends calendar user info BrandonSanderson.com Previous Previous Next Next

Advertisement

Mistborn - A great Reader Mail Question
Weblog for Writer Brandon Sanderson
mistborn
[info]mistborn
Add to Memories
Tell a Friend
A great Reader Mail Question

I posted that other email I got that was somewhat negative, but the overwhelming majority are very encouraging and thoughtful.  I got one piece recently from a reader named Matt which got me thinking.  It relates to A MEMORY OF LIGHT, and so I figured I'd answer it here.

Brandon - My name is Matt, and I have been following your blog posts and website since you were announced as the writer for AMOL. A question to ask occurred to me today that I don't think I ever saw in any of your interviews/posts about being selected to write the book. As a fan, is a part of you disappointed to read the ending of the story the way you did, that is through RJ's notes and not after reading an entire book?

Excellent question!  My answer follows:

It was indeed a different experience to read through the outline and materials, with the holes and occasional vague sections, rather than reading a complete novel. A little bit of me is regretful. Of all the readers and fans out there, I'm one of the few who won't be able to experience this book for the first time in its complete form. Mr. Jordan's assistants and wife have probably been in that boat for years!

And yet, I am a writer, and I don't look at an outline the same way that a regular reader might. The closest approximation I can make is to origami masters. If you go and look at their websites, they will often release 'patterns' that go with a new piece of origami they've developed. The pattern is just a sheet of paper with lines on it. I look at that, and all I see are lines. But to another origami master, that pattern reveals the exact method used to create the piece. They can look at the pattern and see the finished product.

This outline was kind of like that for me, particularly since the ending was the most complete section. I could look at it, and my mind filled in the gaps, adding the foreshadowings and character climaxes that had come before, taking the hints and the outline chunks that Mr. Jordan wrote and putting them all together. It didn't feel like reading a complete book, but I felt like I could SEE that complete book as he would have written it, and that has become my guide in writing it myself.

(I might also note at the end here that one thing I forgot to include in my email to him is that while I didn't get to read the final book like you all will, I DID get to find out what happened at the end of the series a good two years ahead of anyone else!)

I really need to get some annotations posted this week.  Sorry for all of you waiting!  They're coming.  As a consolation, you can see that my primary goal of getting 10k of AMoL was accomplished last week, and I was able to add 3% to the counter.

Comments
raisinfish From: [info]raisinfish Date: May 13th, 2008 07:37 am (UTC) (Link)
Huh. I have thoughts about this. I'll talk to you about them later.
alanajoli From: [info]alanajoli Date: May 13th, 2008 02:22 pm (UTC) (Link)
I love the origami analogy. I could see it being similar for looking at a sewing pattern or a floor-plan as well--those things mystify me, but and outline makes good sense. :)
graypattern From: [info]graypattern Date: May 23rd, 2008 09:03 pm (UTC) (Link)

Books 5 through 10

The same argument you've heard a thousand times, but I want to add my piece to the puzzle, repetitive though it may be.
Of course 5 through 10 were padded. I'm reading from start to finish (it's the second reread for 4 to 11) and I can feel it's a five book series. Once the Chosen started coming back to life and we can write half a book on rescuing Faile and another half a book on Elayne's succession battles, we have gone to 'this series is now endless' land. And why not, I'd would buy every book, hard cover prices all the way through 50. But, I can still tell what is "the series" and what is the continuing saga. It's the first 100 or so pages and the last or so 100 pages that are the series, everytime in 5 through 11. With enough hints we were heading for endless
From: (Anonymous) Date: May 23rd, 2008 09:08 pm (UTC) (Link)

Re: Books 5 through 10

Weird, got cutoff in the middle of posting.. with enough hints were heading for endless wonder in book four to make me believe that Robert Jordan had a plan but buy the time books 1-3 sell a bajillion copies, and he loves it, he just had to let it go down every avenue it ever could.
Books 1 through 3 had action, crisis, resolution every other page. Period. No time for reflection and please no more "it' was cold, not too cold, but cold enough,", I was scared, but not too scared, still scared, even though I wasn't scared and not a ridiculous amount of sword moves without repeating!... the duck flies around the sentry"... I don't think there is any sense in denying it...though I have been wrong before... without having to write a word and the easies job in the world, critic, I think Book 12 has to be action, crisis, resolution all the way though, which maybe just maybe won't take 10,000 pages after all.
Gray
4 comments or Leave a comment
profile
mistborn
User: [info]mistborn
Name: mistborn
calendar
Back July 2009
1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031
about this journal
Brandon Sanderson writes epic fantasy novels for Tor Books. Find his novels, MISTBORN and ELANTRIS in any fine bookstore. More information on his website.
page summary
tags